TL;DR
In the US, you genuinely need: term life, health (employer or ACA marketplace), long-term disability, and an emergency fund. You almost certainly do not need: whole life, universal life, indexed universal life, or "infinite banking" products. Term covers the income-replacement need; the second set bundles overpriced insurance with poor-return investing.
Two Different Problems, Two Different Tools
Insurance solves two distinct problems:
- Income replacement for dependents if you die. Temporary — you need it while children are dependent and you have a mortgage. Once kids are independent and the mortgage is paid off, you typically don't need life insurance anymore.
- Catastrophic medical, disability, and liability costs. Lifelong and unbounded — a single hospitalisation in the US can run six figures, and an unsuccessful auto accident lawsuit can run seven figures.
Mixing these two through "permanent" or "cash-value" life insurance is how most Americans lose money on insurance.
1. Term Life Insurance
Who needs it: anyone with dependents (spouse without independent income, children, dependent parents) or significant joint debt (mortgage, business).
Who doesn't need it: single people with no dependents; retirees whose kids are independent and whose mortgage is paid; people whose investment portfolio already covers all obligations.
How much: 10–12× annual income, plus outstanding mortgage. A 35-year-old earning $120K with a $400K mortgage and two young kids: roughly $1.5–$2M of term cover.
Term length: match the term to when your kids will be independent and your mortgage paid off. Most people in their 30s should buy a 20- or 30-year level term policy.
Cost reality check: a healthy 35-year-old non-smoker can buy $1M of 30-year level term for $50–$70/month. Insurers like Haven Life, Ladder, Bestow, Banner, Protective, and Pacific Life all offer near-equivalent products. Get quotes from at least three.
What to skip:
- Whole life and universal life policies. Premiums 8–15× term equivalents, "cash value" growth of 3–4% (sometimes negative for years due to fees), and salespeople motivated by enormous commissions.
- Mortgage life insurance (sold by the lender to pay off the mortgage if you die). Pure overpriced single-purpose product. A regular term policy for the mortgage amount + cover for income replacement is simpler and cheaper.
- AD&D policies as primary life insurance. They only pay out for accidental death — most deaths aren't accidents.
2. Health Insurance
Who needs it: everyone. The US has the most expensive healthcare system in the world; uninsured ICU stays can cost $300K+. Going uninsured is the highest-risk financial bet most Americans can make.
Where to get it:
- Employer plan — usually best for full-time employees. Employer typically pays 60–80% of the premium.
- ACA marketplace (healthcare.gov or your state exchange) — for self-employed, freelancers, early retirees. Premium subsidies are significant for households earning under 400% of FPL (~$120K for a family of four).
- COBRA — temporary continuation of an employer plan after job loss. Expensive (you pay the full premium + 2% admin fee) but useful as a bridge.
- Spouse's plan — sometimes cheaper than your own employer plan; check both.
What to look for:
- Out-of-pocket maximum — the most you'll pay in a year. For a 2025 ACA bronze plan this is capped at $9,200 individual / $18,400 family. Lower is better.
- Network adequacy — confirm your doctors and your nearest hospital are in-network.
- HSA-eligibility if you have a high-deductible plan — triple tax advantage on contributions, growth, and qualified medical withdrawals.
3. Long-Term Disability Insurance
Who needs it: anyone earning meaningful income.
Why this matters more than people think: the probability of a working-age American becoming long-term disabled is roughly 3× higher than the probability of dying before retirement. Yet most Americans have no individual disability cover and rely entirely on a thin employer policy.
How much: 60–70% of pre-tax income, with payouts to age 65 (or 67). Employer LTD policies typically cap payouts and have generous "any occupation" definitions after 24 months — making it harder to claim.
Get individual coverage via insurers like Guardian, MassMutual, Northwestern Mutual, Principal, or Standard. Look for:
- "Own occupation" definition for the entire benefit period (vs "any occupation" after 24 months — much weaker)
- Non-cancellable, guaranteed renewable
- Cost-of-living adjustment rider
- Future increase option
Cost: for a 35-year-old earning $120K, a quality individual LTD policy with "own occ" definition runs $1,500–$3,000/year — roughly the cost of one nice family vacation.
4. Critical Illness Insurance
Who needs it: mid-income earners with dependents and limited cash reserves.
What it covers: lump-sum payout on diagnosis of cancer, heart attack, stroke, etc. Less critical in the US than in countries where health insurance is weaker, because US health insurance with a manageable out-of-pocket max already covers most of the medical cost.
Most useful as: an employer voluntary benefit at $5–$15/month, when offered. As a standalone product, often poor value vs simply having a robust emergency fund and good disability cover.
5. Other Coverage
Auto liability: carry state minimums plus an umbrella policy. State minimums (often $25K/$50K) are dangerously low — a single bad accident can result in a judgment well into seven figures. A $1–$2M umbrella policy is typically $200–$400/year.
Renters/homeowners: standard, almost always required. Make sure liability coverage stacks with your umbrella.
Pet insurance: a luxury for most; often cheaper to self-insure with a savings buffer.
What to Skip Aggressively
Whole life, universal life, indexed universal life. Marketed as "permanent insurance with savings." In reality: term-equivalent insurance + a high-fee, low-return savings vehicle. The "buy term and invest the difference" alternative wins by enormous margins over 20+ years.
"Infinite banking" / "be your own banker" products. Whole life policies marketed as a personal lending vehicle. The fees, surrender charges, and opportunity cost vs investing in index funds make this a wealth-destruction product for nearly everyone outside specific high-net-worth estate-planning niches.
Cancer-only insurance, accident-only insurance, hospital indemnity insurance. Narrow, overpriced specialty products that fill gaps you should fill with comprehensive health coverage and an emergency fund.
Extended warranties on consumer electronics. Almost always a losing bet — pocket the premium yourself.
The Order of Operations
- Health insurance — non-negotiable.
- Term life sized to 10–12× income + mortgage.
- Long-term disability at 60–70% of income, "own occ" definition.
- Auto + umbrella liability.
- Renters/homeowners with adequate liability.
Total annual cost for a 35-year-old family of four: roughly $3,000–$6,000/year for everything outside of health insurance — a small fraction of what most families spend annually, for protection against truly catastrophic events.
A Note on Disclosure and Underwriting
Disclose every health condition, lifestyle factor, and family history accurately. Insurers can and do rescind policies for material misrepresentation within the contestability period (typically 2 years), and even after for fraud. Honesty at application is what makes the premium meaningful.
Want a personalised view of your insurance, investments, and retirement together? AI Financial Planner →